Huberman: Mentor Mindset for Growth & Motivation

Mentor Mindset: Navigating Social Appraisal and Growth

Huberman and his guest discuss the concept of the mentor mindset and how it relates to growth and performance. They explore the idea that people are heavily influenced by social and self-appraisal, with a strong desire to be liked and avoid negative feedback.

Receiving criticism or poor evaluations can be painful, especially when delivered publicly. However, the key to personal growth lies in how one responds to and utilizes this information.

While positive feedback is always welcome, it’s the constructive criticism that ultimately drives improvement. Embracing a mentor mindset allows individuals to view negative feedback as an opportunity for growth rather than a personal attack.

The Mentor’s Dilemma

Yeager discusses the concept of the “mentor’s dilemma,” which refers to the challenge leaders face when trying to provide critical feedback while simultaneously motivating individuals to embrace and overcome that criticism.

The solution to this dilemma is to appeal to high standards while assuring the person that they are capable of meeting those standards with the right support and effort. This approach is termed a “mentor mindset,” which strikes a balance between being an enforcer (high standards, low support) and a protector (low standards, high support).

Yeager emphasizes that the effectiveness of this method lies not in the specific words used but in the experience of dignity and respect conveyed to the individual when they are vulnerable and questioning their worth or the support they will receive from those in authority.

The Emotion-Driven Brain: How Affective Regions Train the Prefrontal Cortex

Yeager and Huberman discuss the role of emotions in driving motivation and learning. Yeager highlights Dweck’s work, which suggests that the affective regions of the brain often teach the prefrontal cortex how to pursue goals effectively within a given social context.

Huberman agrees that emotions drive tactical decisions and learning, and raises the question of whether the core emotion driving motivation matters. He wonders if doing things out of love leads to faster learning compared to doing things out of fear.

Yeager cites Kahneman’s prospect theory, which argues that the fear of loss can be more motivating than the prospect of gain. However, he believes that focusing too much on narrow self-interest underestimates people’s capacity for meaningful contributions to others.

Yeager emphasizes the importance of creating opportunities for people to make beautiful contributions to the world, citing examples of the best managers and coaches who support and encourage their team members to achieve great things.

How Great Mentors Motivate: The Power of Focusing on Potential Impact

Yeager shares insights from his conversation with renowned basketball coach Chip Engelland. Instead of motivating players with the fear of losing their position in the league, Engelland focuses on the prospect of what players can do for their families and future generations by developing a reliable jump shot.

Huberman suggests that when we find ourselves in challenging situations, focusing on what we can do for others or the world can be the best way forward. Yeager agrees and extends this idea to art and intellectual history, referencing Viktor Frankl’s experience in concentration camps.

Frankl’s survival was fueled not by the fear of death, but by the meaning of the work he could do for the world if he survived. Huberman appreciates the blend of philosophical and data-driven insights in the conversation.

The Power of Mentorship: Elevating Careers and Changing Lives

Yeager shares the story of Steph Akamoto, a manager who mentored a young employee named Salani at Microsoft. Akamoto recognized Salani’s potential and encouraged her to make a contribution to the company that would help her learn new skills and advance her career.

Salani took on the challenge, delivering her regular job responsibilities while also creating a dashboard to track the progress of new hires in the management process. This extra effort showcased her abilities, leading to a promotion and setting her on a path to a leadership role at Microsoft.

Akamoto’s mentorship not only benefited Salani but also her own team’s performance. The experience of positively influencing someone’s life brought Akamoto great joy and satisfaction. Yeager emphasizes that contributing to both the company and the people around you can be in everyone’s long-term self-interest, without requiring anyone to be a martyr.

Huberman agrees that doing things one loves, such as learning and sharing information to benefit others, is the best of both worlds. It allows for personal fulfillment while also positively impacting the lives of others.

Mentoring Diverse Students in Physics

Yeager discusses the work of a physics professor at Vanderbilt who mentors a diverse group of graduate students through bridge programs. These programs pre-admit students to a master’s program at a local HBCU and then to a PhD program based on their performance, rather than solely on GRE scores.

The professor’s lab focuses on developing students’ skills through rigorous critique and support. Weekly lab meetings involve presenting and critiquing each other’s work, which prepares students for conferences and helps them grow as physicists.

Huberman emphasizes the importance of gleaning critique from the correct sources, such as a supportive community focused on a shared mission. He also highlights the significance of drive and motivation in selecting students, rather than relying solely on standardized test scores.

Yeager notes that while standardized tests could theoretically promote equity, they often end up reflecting advantages in education and resources. He argues that the ultimate proof of a student’s potential lies in their ability to produce great work in their field when given the proper mentoring and training.

More From this Episode

Leave a Comment